My Battle between Building an Author’s Email List or finishing Fiddling with Death

Since my first novel, My Splendid Concubine, came out in December 2007, I’ve done almost everything legal to promote my books. Still, there’s one promotion method I haven’t tried, creating an author’s email list that includes free reader magnets.

“An author’s email list is a collection of email addresses from readers who have opted-in to receive updates and news from the author, allowing them to directly communicate with their audience about new book releases, promotions, and other relevant information; while a ‘reader magnet’ is a free piece of content, like a short story excerpt, bonus chapter, or character art, that an author offers to potential readers in exchange for their email address, essentially enticing them to join the email list and learn more about the author’s work.” 

I tried and failed repeatedly over two to three years to build one of these email lists offering free reader magnets. I enrolled in an online course from a trusted provider, but the videos included were outdated and did not align with the interfaces of Book Funnel and Mailer-lite. Then I turned to Book Funnel and Mailer-lite how-to-videos, but they threw too much information too fast in short, confusing videos that also didn’t match their own dashboards, so I stopped to save my sanity.

Still, I did use a system comparable to email lists and reader magnets. That was my first blog launched in 2010, to support My Splendid Concubine. The thousands of blog posts I wrote and published on iLook China over a period of about five years did the same thing reader magnets offer.  They attracted readers interested in China and not all of them subscribed, but many bought the novel. That blog still has 627 subscribers, who signed up to receive notices of blog posts about China.

Between 2010 and 2015, when I was blogging regularly, over 46,000 copies of my first novel were sold. Since I stopped publishing new blog posts regularly in 2015, sales dropped dramatically, but still added another 3,386 sales over the last nine years, in addition to 666,022 KU page reads, adding up to another 624 books.

I have one unpublished reader magnet that was written to support my Josh Kavanagh Thrillers (the box set costs less than buying all three individually), with another reader magnet in the works. No more waiting. I will publish what I already have and write more reader magnets that I will publish on these two blogs:

https://wordpress.com/view/lloydlofthouse.org

https://www.lloydlofthouse.com/search/label/Blog

I haven’t given up on the idea of building an author’s email list. That also doesn’t mean I will. What I did was stop squandering time and money, and went on to complete the third book in my thriller series instead.

Fiddling with Death is scheduled to be out on February 10, 2025.

Smug tyrants. Battered heroes. With an insider thwarting their every move, can these resourceful special operatives defend democracy?

Never for Glory, the second thriller, was delivered June 2023.

The first thriller in the series, with 305 ratings on Amazon and a 4.3 average, The Patriot Oath, came out June 2021.

Donald Trump loyalists hate The Patriot Oath.

As I write this post, over 84% of reader ratings are positive. Please read the 16% that aren’t. Most of them are from Donald Trump loyalists. This thriller focuses on the US Constitutional oath Josh Kavanagh, the main character, took to defend the US Constitution against all enemies domestic and foreign when he joined the US Marines. I took the same oath when I became a US Marine before being sent to Vietnam. George Washington took the same oath when he became president in 1789. In fact, ever US president took that same oath.

No other US president throughout US history demands loyalty over the US Constitution like Donald Trump has and still does. Trump also became a traitor on January 6, 2021, by inciting a failed violent coup attempt to grab power and keep it. That was the same day Donald Trump broke the oath he took in January 2017 to defend the U.S. Constitution.

Responses to “My Battle between Building an Author’s Email List or finishing Fiddling with Death”

  1. Susan Lee Schwartz Avatar

    You Knock me out!SusanSent from my iPhone

  2. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Avatar

    Promoting over writing, the age-old dilemma for us independents. It’s even worse for me, with my limited ability to do ANYTHING.

    So, when I have a brain (not all days) and some energy (ditto), I go for the writing first.

    But I can’t ignore opportunities completely, so sometimes I will spend that precious capital sending an email to a potential reader/reviewer – and some of these appeals are successful (I run at about 50% acceptance).

    Right now I’m doing end-of-year tax stuff that MUST be done in 2024, so I’m doing neither – but it’s not fair to saddle the husband with ALL the work when I can do some of it.

    Reading has become a luxury – but I’ll get back to it when I can.

    Best I can do for now.

    As always, impressed by your ability to do so many things – and still write.

    1. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

      Have you tried Net Galley? I’m giving it a first try and should know if it works before the 2nd week in February 2025. Not wanting to deal with learning how to use Net Galley, I hired a book blog publist to do the work for me. I think the price was reasonable.

      1. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Avatar

        The setup always takes so long – I don’t even start. I think I did a Netgalley joint one a while back – not a single sale.

        I’d be interested in your book blog publicist – but even that will take effort.

      2. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        Net Galley is a review site and must be used and completed prior to the release date. Amazon doesn’t allow us to offer free reads after publication unless we offer them free through KDP. No sales through Net Galley. If the sun shines, a few positive reviews that may be posted on Goodreads and/or Amazon. If only dark stormy clouds, maybe no reviews or only negative ones.

        It’s a gamble, but publishing is a gamble every time we release another book. We never know what’s going to happen or if maybe nothing will happen ever.

      3. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        I used one book blog publisist for Net Galley

        https://xpressobooktours.com/

        Xpresso Book Tours handled Net Galley for me – I went with the shortest length one for $65 to see what happens.

        And the next link is for a two week book blog tour that will end on February 10th, the day before the 7-day KCD that’s part of the release promotion starts. I also landed a BookBub Early Release for Less Feature for Fiddling with Death that will run on February 11th, with emails going out to more than a million thriller readers who signed up with BookBub to get those feature deal emails. BookBub turned down the first two thrillers in the series more than once. For some reason, they said yes to number three.

        https://www.rabtbooktoursandpr.com/

        I used RABTbook tours for a short two-week book tour, and they’ll use the same review copy posted on net Galley for any Book Bloggers interested by getting the code link from XPresso. The counter or RABT book tours shows they have more than four million views/visitors. If I recall correft, that one cost $75. I’ll let you know the results when the sun comes out after the tour ends on February 17, 2025.

        I started working on the launch date promotion for Fiddling with Death back in November 2024. It’s a multi-layer promotion.

        The only work I did for the book bub publicists was send the two book blog promotion sites a query email and follow ups spread out over time. Then I clicked to pay the invoice through PayPal once we made a deal.

      4. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Avatar

        Thanks! I’ll see if I can do that – sounds simple.

      5. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        The two sites have a lot of different plans. You may have to study them to find a plan that fits your books best.

      6. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        Correction. I just saw my PayPal notes. I paid $57.75 for a two-week book blog tour organized by RABT Book Tours starting 2-5 through 2-17. The tour runs to the end of the seven day KCD for the first book in the series. The book bloggers will have to have finished reading Fiddling with Death by then to post their reviews. That is if anyone signs up and writes reviews.

        Even the BookBub Early Release Feature for Less is a gamble, but one I hope pays off. If even 1% of a milllion readers buys Fiddling with Death, that’s 10,000. Still, maybe no one will.

        Everything authors do is a gamble. From writing,to editing and revisions, to publishing and marketing. The competition for readers eyes is HUGE!

      7. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Avatar

        The competition is smaller than you think – for certain kinds of books, because they take a long time to plot and write.

        The trick – if you don’t write in a popular genre like SFF, thrillers, or romances – is to FIND the readers who like the kind of book you write.

        The more important part for me, though, is to finish the third book in the trilogy – so I can market it as a whole. I have 58 reviews for the first book (you must have thousands for your books!), but only 13 for the second (all 5*, though).

        Working on it.

      8. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        Not thousands, not for my only series. More than 300 ratings for the first one in that one series and less than a 100 for the 2nd. No telling how #3 will fare. My first single out the gate back in December 2007, has more than 1,400. I could have turned tha to ne into a series but didn’t. I thought about it but decided no. BIG MISTAKE! That only took about 16 years after spending eight years researching, writing, editing and revising My Splendid Concubine.

        I do not know if I mentoined this before, since I learned about this in an email newsletter last week, but Matthew J. Holmes, the Brit I’m learning how to use Facebook ADs from, shared with us how his wife’s one series with four books is doing. He’s said they only advertise the first book in that series and nothing else.

        His wife Lori Holmes writes Fantasy and has 13 titles on her Amazon author page. Hubby does the promotion and doesn’t write fiction. Last week, he shared with his followers that 90% of the royalties they earn comes from that one series and the other nine titles are responble for the other 10%.

        He also said about 20 to 30% of what they earn in royalties each month covers the costs of promotion.

        He also shared a screen shot of what his wife earned in June or July for one month. Royalties for that one month were more than $10,000. Matt said it can take weeks to months before a succesful series starts showing a profit after starting promoting it with Amazon and Facebook Ads.

        Matt said as soon as his wife has the 2nd book out in a new series she started with one already out, they will start advertising that series too. They started adversting her first series after the 2nd book came out, too. Two books count as a series, according to him. They didn’t publish a box set until after the fourth book in the first series.

      9. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Avatar

        I’ve seen Matt’s promo for his method – no way I can DO it, but maybe you can.

      10. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        It took me weeks to get through all of Matt’s “many” videos and I’ve marked some for more go throughs. My impression: Amazon Ads are simple to set up compared to Facebook’s COMPLEX advertising dashboard. I have some Facebook ADs running now in the US for only the first book in my thriller series. At least once a week, I check in to document their progress. Lots of data to go over. Actually, I think it is too much data to go over. Gives me headaches and eyes strain. Maybe in time, I’ll learn all the steps and it will seem easier. I hope. The first Facebook test for ADs, known as a DCT (I think), was launced halfway through November. Sales and page reads started to increase within a day or two and are running higher than I’m used to. But they are not running a profit yet. If I’m forutnate, I may break even or close. Facebook ADs dramatically cost more to run than Amazon Ads, but also seem to generate more results.

      11. Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Avatar

        You overestimate my energy – you put in a lot of hours of hard work learning, and you’re still not turning a profit, which I can’t afford to spend my time on.

        I’ll look at the publicists you suggested first – it’s all on the to do list, but I’m stuck doing some tax things, not writing, and I’m completely drained. You can’t just not be sick when necessary; instead, ‘necessary’ makes the stress worse, and the energy less available.

        Taking another nap!

      12. Lloyd Lofthouse Avatar

        I understand.

Leave a reply to Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.